Africa-Press – Namibia. A recent opinion by Legal Assistance Centre researcher Dianne Hubbard, published by The Namibian, argues that mandatory DNA testing of newborns violates privacy, dignity, and equality.
While these concerns deserve weight, the argument overlooks equally vital values: a child’s right to identity, a man’s right to legal certainty, and the role of accountability in strengthening the family unit.
The Namibian Constitution does not apply selectively. While blanket, coercive testing could raise privacy concerns under Article 13, rights are not absolute. The real question is one of proportionality: Is there a better way to ensure legal certainty and protect a child’s identity?
The claim that DNA testing harms women by exposing their sexual history is overstated. Testing establishes biological parentage; it does not criminalise sexuality.
Maternity is a biological certainty at birth; paternity is not. This asymmetry creates a legal imbalance. When a man is registered as a father without verification, he assumes lifelong financial and emotional obligations. If later proven otherwise, the harm is concrete and enduring. Equality under Article 10 requires that both parents have access to certainty, rather than one party relying solely on trust.
Perhaps most compelling is the position of the child. Under Article 15, a child’s identity is foundational to their psychological development. Discovering ‘paternity fraud’ in one’s teens could cause profound trauma. Early knowledge prevents this disruption and the potential for domestic violence that often erupts when deception is uncovered years later.
The suggestion that accountability increases violence deserves scrutiny. In most societal contexts, transparency deters misconduct rather than provoking it. Uncertainty and suspicion are far more volatile than the truth.
A constitutionally sound approach would be to make DNA testing routinely available at birth on a voluntary, confidential basis. This removes the stigma and costly litigation currently required to prove parentage, respecting privacy while promoting equality.
The Constitution does not protect deception; it protects fairness and the rule of law. Framing this debate solely as a threat to women’s rights ignores the legitimate interests of fathers and children.
Certainty, handled respectfully, strengthens families.
Truth is not the enemy of the home.
– Tuhafeni Hailonga
For More News And Analysis About Namibia Follow Africa-Press
